When Your Payments Brand Content Doesn’t Stand Out

Featured image for payments brand article

Over the past decade I’ve worked with a number of fintech payment brands. Embedded finance platforms, payment gateways, cross-border remittance platforms: Payments certainly accelerated my writing career as I treaded into each sub-niche. But today payments platform marketing suffers from an ailment common to niche software solutions:

Poor payments brand differentiation.

It may seem inconsequential when leadership traces hard revenue to sales teams, customers are budget-first buyers, and nuanced marketing feels superfluous.

But migrations from older or other systems is expensive and buyers need support to determine if your platform is their best bet. Content often fails flat in this regard, leaving customers to sift through an endless listicle of products that look and feel the same.

The payment brands negative content trap

Many fintech companies heavily focus on primary features for selling: Compliance, security, frictionless, easy, and customizable payments, and savings. Every single one, across sub-niches, depends on these factors to entice customers.

And that’s the problem.

A good portion of these platforms do offer unique solutions. They are not all carbon copies of each other. However, even when similarities appear, they fail to delve into their real differentiators.

Readers rarely get lengthy customer stories or interviews, watch integrations or migrations in real-time, or discuss real shortcuts, problems, and scenarios. It’s all product-based marketing with a brittle layer of narrative.

One of the things I request in content discovery sessions is whether or not their marketing team has access to leadership and customer service teams. Now, I ask for tangible and practical access—not clips and boilerplate responses, but real interview time to pick their brain on trends that matter.

This type of narrative marketing takes time. It’s lower in the funnel. The search volume feels too low.

But this approach to content helps software brands, payments included, to stand out.

There’s one more key issue stands in the way of integrating real narrative marketing, and it dovetails with overemphasis on similar features: The idea of frictionless.

The obsession with frictionless

It’s a buzzword now, but when payments first started using it, it attempted to describe the smooth workflow of a modern process. My college poetry professor hated the word “flow” for the same reason—while it originally mirrored rhythm of the poem, it had become a clutch for writers and marketers. It began to mean everything, and then it meant nothing.

We are a society obsessed with frictionless encounters. What we mean is convenient, so convenient you don’t have to think about it. Now it’s bolstered as the primary feature for many products. It’s easy, it’s convenient, it’s empty, it’s thoughtless. Frictionless is now a negative, not a positive.

A frictionless product can create mistrust, forgetfulness, and anxiety. Your payment gateway may offer an amazing whirlwind of an experience for a clothing brand, but what happens when the end consumer overspends and ends up in debt? Or misses a chance to apply a discount code? What happens if a money transfer is mistakenly sent to the wrong account, or fraudsters easily mirror legitimate payment gateways to scam end-users?

These are real issues that stem from something begin too easy, the barrier-of-entry too low. It’s easy to shift this burden to end-users: Shouldn’t they know better? But design matters; If something is too slick, you’re prone to fall.

It’s hardly a selling point, even with marketing. A client who is investing the process typically yields better results; the right friction is a nutrient. Friction at the right touchpoints can elevate your brand and foster a sense of security.

Collaborative narrative structure in practice

When transitioning to the solution, I’m going to cover collaborative narrative structure. This process involves the writer, marketing team, and leadership working together to develop a stronger and differentiated messaging.

I want to give an example, starting with cost and the old way of doing things. Most of my clients are budget conscious. Image writing two posts describing basic payments terminology: What is PCI-DSS? and The Future of Embedded Finance at $550 each ($1,100).

SEO will tell you these are decent topics—high competition, but high search volume. Maybe refine these topics further so they are lower competition. But I bet these articles produce very little quality traffic and engagement, regardless. The general topics are bloated, saturated. And your CTA at the end is limited: What will you discuss, that you meet the qualifications for PCI-DSS compliance, something every reputable platform does? Furthermore, most of these topics are so general that the mirror every other article from every other brand.

This isn’t a quality investment.

Now, instead, imagine investing in a $1,000 customer story on how X Client Used Reduced Chargeback Dispute Time to Develop New Awesome Product to that links to an upcoming or in-demand webinar on a fraud management in your payments software. That means something. That’s tangible. It’s easy to repurpose into social media posts, include in press releases, or integration to sales materials. With the right approach, it can also boost content SEO. The initial cost his higher but the long-term value is significantly higher.

Maybe you don’t want to do (or can’t do) a customer story. You could use the same amount (or probably more, depending on length) on a workbook showing users how to implement certain strategies, step-by-step, with your platform, and why these strategies work.

These content projects takes longer. They may even be slightly more expensive. But this structured content is more relevant to customers, more complimentary to your product, and more importantly, it differentiates you from the competition—even if only in the realm of customer satisfaction.

Rather than one more article on how you also have industry-standard security features, show the reader what that actually looks like. That illustration is far more powerful than a features list, and will better resonate with your target audience.

Developing narrative structure

Creating what assets to produce requires knowing your narrative message, which elaborates on your general brand messaging and product information. It requires in-depth knowledge of your customers and a deep understanding of the not only the problem-solution component of your product, but also conflicts, characters, underlying trends, trade-offs, and future-forecasts. It exchanges a surface-level plot with a resonating structure.

Adding a narrative structure layer can feel like one more thing when you have twenty-other tasks today alone. It can help to have an outside player with industry knowledge in your corner. Whether it’s getting everything done or brainstorming creative ways to reach your end users, you want a writer and strategist who thinks critically and cares about your success.

If having a writer versed in narrative structure and industry norms sounds like a solution for you, the next step is to see if we’re a good fit. Book a brief discovery call today.