On the surface level, content for nonprofit and for-profit organizations appears the same. Industries that require marketing efforts to abide by specific compliance codes may seem to have some additional nuance. Still, most content types and strategies may seem applicable to your organization.
There are some marketing laws that require extra due diligence from nonprofits.
For example, all businesses are required to avoid misleading customers. Nonprofits must disclose how donations will be used, campaign periods, and other information. In addition, nonprofits must also be transparent about:
- Matching gifts
- Annual giving
- Planning gifts
- How the charity benefits from sales
All of these items, however, don’t necessarily impact content strategy, except strategically placing disclosures to ensure transparency without adversely affecting content flow.
What’s in a Nonprofit Content Strategy?
Outside of maintaining transparency, a nonprofit content strategy should resemble that of a for-profit organization. The main differentiators stem from audience expectations.
For most businesses, a customer expects to benefit from their immediate purchase. Nonprofits must often cope with convincing donors of long-term benefits for themselves and immediate positive benefits for others. The Immigrant and Refugee Outreach Center’s (IROC) immediately benefit incoming refugees by helping new refugees acclimate to US society. In contrast, donuts benefit long-term through both personal fulfillment and ensuring successful integration.
The primary challenge for most nonprofits is in the strategy foundation—what motivates your specific donors. Knowing this enables you to draft compelling content campaigns.
8 Key Considerations for Your Nonprofit Content Strategy
Below, I’ve compiled 8 main sections any content strategy should have. At the end of each section description, I’ve included one simple task to summarize what to do next.
The longest part of this process tends to be researching your competitors and generating content keywords.
1. Goals & Metrics
Determining how you measure success comes first. When it comes to content, you may be looking for things like:
- Website traffic
- User engagement
- Form signups
- Content downloads
Additionally, donor revenue is also used. However, it can be challenging to tie content to increases or decreases in revenue directly. A donor may read an article online and donate at a physical event a month later. For that reason, revenue should not be the only metric.
Instead, it can help you look at what you can manage. The SEO-based metrics of website traffic and form signups can instead help you better gauge your overall reach. If revenue does not increase alongside these metrics, it can mean a few different things:
- The call-to-action (CTA) is too weak
- Your potential donors do not have excess income to donate
- You are giving away too much content for free—i.e., you may want to consider gated content, such as an ebook that required email signups, to better retarget potential donors.
Likewise, website traffic, downloads, and engagement are all items you have more control over than donations. Using improving these metrics as your objective, as opposed to generally increasing donations, can help steer your strategy.
Task: List your primary objective and KPI. You can track these on a spreadsheet or via other reporting software.
2. Budget
Another significant contains is your budget. For most markers and founders, there isn’t much you can do about your starting resources.
Staying lean is the best strategy, especially with a limited budget. This can mean prioritizing your distribution channels, emphasizing repurposing content, and keeping a small team.
However, it’s important to consider how much of your budget you should allow for content writing to see results. Quality matters more than quantity, but how much you publish can affect your overall website ranking. At the very least, more pages translate into more internal links and more keywords covered.
In my personal experience, I have seen significant jumps in traffic after 30, 75, and 100 posts on a website.
But, again, quality matters more. Poor quality content, whether AI- or human-written, is regularly downgraded on Google Search. You will likely have to balance producing good work with speed while growing your content library.
Task: How much would it cost to meet your objectives? If your estimation is over budget, what aspects cost the most? How can you maximize your funds?
3. Ideal Donors
Discovering who your donors are and what motivates them enables you to design a content strategy that attracts similar contributors. A research report published in the Journal of Philanthropy and Marketing found that there are 8 reasons why people donate to nonprofits1:
- Altruism
- Awareness of need
- Solicitation
- Costs and benefits
- Reputation
- Psychological Benefits
- Values, such as religious and cultural beliefs2
- Efficiency
But there are other factors, too, such as a nonprofit’s affiliation3 or financial reporting transparency.4
Task: Determine why your ideal donor gives to your organization—which of the above is most likely successful?
4. Competitors
Competitor research is essential when it comes to creating content, just as it does to business operations. You will want to review competitor websites, social media, and other content materials to determine what they are writing about. Some SEO-content products, like Ahrefs, Semrush, etc, can give you a glimpse of how successful they are..
However, the main reason to look at competitors is to identify gaps and differentiate your content.
Task: List your top 5 direct and 5 content competitors. These organizations may differ greatly. But they should give you insight into what has already been done, what’s working, and where your nonprofit fits in.
5. Content angle
All content types apply to content marketing for nonprofit organizations. What matters more is the framing of your content—and this will hinge directly on your ideal donor’s profile.
At the same time, there are a few additional best practices to be aware of:
- Focus on individual stories. Most people are more likely to help an individual than a group, a psychological response known as the Idenfitfible Victim Effect.5
- Be transparent. Your organization is changing the world, but it’s best to avoid hyperbole and instead focus on transparency and clarity—no one benefits from unsupported claims.
- Lean on partnerships. Affiliations with other organizations, nonprofit or otherwise, often attract credibility and attention from more donors. Working together with partners or even sponsors can help to boost visibility.
- Ensure there is a funnel. Just like with commercial organizations, you want a content flow to drive potential donors from discovery to contributing. This can include multiple pieces of content, such as blog posts, newsletters, success stories, videos, and other content types.
Task: Take your donor profiles and consider 10 angles for your organization’s content based on their motivations.
6. Keywords
Even with the advent of AI search, keywords represent what questions or interests your donors may have. Use them to create a concentrated content library.
My best practices for keyword research include the following:
- Keywords should be relevant to your mission
- Keywords adjacent to your organization may be used if they complement your mission
- Monthly volume should be greater than 20 but less than 2000, especially starting out
- Competition should be “possible” or less, as defined by Semrush
It’s important to remember that low-volume keywords may skyrocket later. For that reason, it helps to listen to leadership and determine what trends or challenges might be upcoming.
Task: Use Semrush or another tool to accumulate relevant keywords. Then, apply your content angles to them. This should generate a list of potential topics for your strategy.
7. Language and voice index
It’s important to write content that mirrors donor expectations and is relatable. While your specific tone may change, your voice should not.
For this reason, it helps to have a brief language and voice guide. This will prevent confusion among different contributors, reduce content production questions, and preserve consistency. Some key areas to include are:
- Your brand adjectives
- Grammar or spelling specifications
- Header capitalization rules
- Lists of words you do and do not want to use
- Brand-specific words and phrases
Task: Review past content and create a 3-7 page document that details your language and voice guidelines.
8. Maintenance Spreadsheet
Finally, you’ll want a spreadsheet tracking your content pages. You will need to update them periodically based on their performance, and having a clear record makes it easy to do so. You may even decide to focus on updating these pages rather than creating new content right off the bat.
You’ll want to track the following information:
- The page’s URL
- The targeting keyword
- When it was last published
- The author
- A like to the content brief, if available
- Current ranking
Task: Create a spreadsheet and begin listing your content.
Next Steps: Executing Your Strategy
As a content writer specializing in B2B SEO content strategy and production, I know how chaotic it can be to execute even the most solid content plan. But having a clear, concise strategy makes it far easier to produce and track content performance—and it’s certainly worth the hour spent on hammering out your content fundamentals.
If you’d like feedback on your strategy or need help developing high-quality nonprofit content, schedule a call with me today. Or check out some of my recent work in my portfolio.
Citations
- Osili, U., Hirt, D., & Raghavan, S. (2011). Charitable giving inside and outside the workplace: the role of individual and firm characteristics. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, 16(4), 393-408. https://doi.org/10.1002/nvsm.435
↩︎ - Baqutayan, S., Mohsin, M., Mahdzir, A., & Ariffin, A. (2018). The psychology of giving behavior in islam. Sociology International Journal, 2(2). https://doi.org/10.15406/sij.2018.02.00037
↩︎ - Harris, E. and Neely, D. (2015). Multiple information signals in the market for charitable donations. Contemporary Accounting Research, 33(3), 989-1012. https://doi.org/10.1111/1911-3846.12175
↩︎ - Krishnan, R. and Yetman, M. (2011). Institutional drivers of reporting decisions in nonprofit hospitals. Journal of Accounting Research, 49(4), 1001-1039. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-679x.2011.00413.x
↩︎ - Genevsky, A., Västfjäll, D., Slovic, P., & Knutson, B. (2013). Neural underpinnings of the identifiable victim effect: affect shifts preferences for giving. Journal of Neuroscience, 33(43), 17188-17196. https://doi.org/10.1523/jneurosci.2348-13.2013
↩︎

