It’s happened again: Non-marketers on your team describe to you what they want to see from marketing (we won’t say who, but you know). Their newest, “data-driven” obsession: GEO.
If you’re like me, you may have assuming initially, they were talking about geofencing. But, no. It’s another AI-related “transformation.” Maybe you like AI, maybe you don’t. Either way, allowing individuals with no experience in your domain to dictate your strategy or tech stack is the quickest way to transform marketing into a Frankenstein monster.
Back to the topic at hand: GEO. They want it, you need to decide if it’s worth the investment.
TLDR; My professional opinion is that GEO new word to describe an already generalized approach to content. It’s not a strategy in itself, but you’ll probably end up adding this term to your vocab to ensure your department stays funded.
Defining generative engine optimization
GEO is short for generative engine optimization. Think ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews/Gemini, etc. The idea: Get found and recommended by AI.
Approaching GEO for the first time, it can feel approaching any new platform for the first time. But it’s not quite that simple, because of how large language models (LLM) work.
At the root of any AI platform is a massive database of spaced material — from websites, books, previous chats, and search engines, among other sources. Based on your (or a customer’s) question, the bot pulls sentences information from its database. Sources may or may not be included.
Looking at GEO like this, it’s much less about creating a presence on a platform rather than optimizing the channels you already use. The most important of these? Your website—which means SEO.
AI-centric marketing: The real data
Founders and executive team members gearing up for AI marketing share their perspective: AI is the future and we don’t want to fall behind. FOMO.
And it’s easy to see why. Article after article, LinkedIn post after LinkedIn post is bullish on AI marketing. Traffic from ChatGPT alone grew by double digits last month — logic dictates it’ll overtake Google?
Not quite.
Google and traditional search engines continue to lead in consumer trust, with 99% of AI platform users still using search engines, while only 16.45% of search engine consumers use AI platforms. More damning: Google alone captures 13.7 billion searches a day, with ChatGPT lagging behind at 1 billion.
These numbers might seem inconsequential at face value, but they highlight an important point. Customers are primarily on search engines, not AI. Shifting to an AI-first strategy based on speculation of it continuing to increase is risky and, more often not, unnecessary.
Because if you are already producing branded content, you’ve likely got the AI discoverability covered.
Good GEO is SEO
When AI bots scour their databases, they are identifying contextually relevant content to the user. This is similar to how SEO works for user queries: Relevancy is king and queen.
Optimize your website content to optimize for SEO will likely be your best bet for appearing in AI search results—and validate answers users get from AI or other sources.
But there are some questions that spin off from this:
- How do you measure success with GEO?
- What if you’re doing SEO right and still not getting results?
- How can you best communicate your strategy, AI-influenced or not, to other stakeholders?
Tracking GEO behavior and metrics
Users flock to both GEO and traditional search engines for answers. But for marketing professionals, the nuanced differences matter.
For example, a customer looking for “the top accounting firm near me” on Google will browse through the first page of options, click on one or two websites — especially if they don’t recognize the firms — and skim the websites. Maybe, if proximity matters most, they’ll go to the map and click the website for the closest firm.
An AI-user types in their query, looks at the list, and might ask AI to list the firm’s contact information or numbers. A user with a curious mind might ask the bot for more details about each firm there, before looking up the winner on Google or adding it their phone.
GEO skips the skimming, basically.
This new behavior begs for new metrics. Marketing teams looking for the ROI on AI marketing look at:
- AI citations
- Traffic from AI citations
- % of response inclusion
We know how to track AI marketing. Or, at least, what to track. The system is there for anyone looking to incorporate AI marketing into an existing strategy.
There’s a number of tools that claim to track traffic from AI. I say claim, because I haven’t personally used these features. Many mainstream SEO tools that I am familiar with, like Semrush, say they accurately track AI inclusion. As do other platforms like Heap and Visualping. But GA4 should be enough to get started tracking traffic from these platforms.
What if you’re doing SEO right and still not getting results?
Investing in SEO and content creation doesn’t necessarily guarantee inclusion in AI or search results, for a few reasons:
- Users’ word choice may not align with your mission
- Content has not been updated and search emphasis has changed
- Content is not relevant
- There’s not enough content
- Content is not well written, helpful, or unique
These options highlight a particular challenge with SEO, what I call over-optimization. Emphasizing keywords over expertise can lead to low-funnel content. Lack of voice or clarity around writing rules can standardize language to the point of being bland. Improper customer targeting, often sacrificed for high-volume keywords, easily keeps sites weighed down.
Rather than investing in a new tool, it’s often better to take a step back and map out your strategy in more detail. Identify areas that could be tested, and then perform those tests.
Some content tests I would recommend for currently published content types are:
- Tracking content metrics pre- and post-update — such as adding new links, data, or imagery.
- Creating expertise-led content on an adjacent topic and comparing results.
- Adding content to a newsletter or social site (with repurposed content in the main post and the link in the comments) to determine engagement.
- Publish a guest post on a similar topic and compare, to see if it’s an site-wide or a topic issue.
- Use ad spend, if available, to test content for high-performing topics or angles.
These tactics are more useful for blogs, webinars, landing pages, case studies, etc. In the past, I would believe most posts can be optimized without resorting to ad spend and guest posting. But both of these have minimal risks and can still provide unique insights into content quality.
How can you best communicate your strategy, AI-influenced or not, to other stakeholders?
Every stakeholder is different. One CEO might be a true-believer, AI might as well be the second coming of Christ, and AI-centric marketing is inevitable. Another might be looking for a competitive advantage, and sees early-adoption of AI marketing as an avenue for success. A third only cares about the bottom-line (and this is not always the CFO!).
There are generally two ways I’m looking at discussing AI.
For those adamantly against adding to their workload or cost:
It’s important to convey the cost of new tools with potential ROI based on your customer base, provide alternatives with a greater change of success, and leverage how these practices will positively impact AI marketing anyway.
For those that don’t care, believe in GEO, or believe AI might be the only avenue to more funding. In that case, fuck it. The reality is that we’re only playing with words. GEO is essentially repackaged SEO—if your stakeholders want to call it that, fine. Add AI tracking to your reports, especially if you already have the software, and keep on at it. It’s not dishonest, it’s using the language they understand to get the results they want. You can either argue about GEO and SEO until you’re blue in the face, or you draft a functioning strategy.
Future-focused marketing
Generative engine optimization may or may not be hype. (I think you can tell where I stand). Regardless, the wheel of time keeps turning and that means you have marketing strategies to deliver. You may use GEO, you may rail against it—the only thing that matters is that you can drive results. And if you can’t make your goals, you can at least identify why or why not, and try again.

