Looking over your commercial insurance copywriting and feeling a long line of Zs?
Let’s be clear: Commercial insurance is one of the most necessary financial products on the market today. But writing compelling copy is hard – or at least, it can feel that way.
After all, insurance for businesses comes with a few caveats:
- Despite being a necessity for the lay businessman, commercial insurance uses highly technical language.
- Financial institutions have a particular set of compliance rules for discussing their products.
- Commercial insurance is a highly personalized product – generalizations aren’t recommended.
So how can commercial insurance businesses stand out in the era of personalized marketing?
Let’s look at some commercial insurance copywriting examples to get a better idea.
New York, New York with Rampart Insurance
For our first example, we fly to the east coast (digitally, of course) to take a look at Rampart Insurance, a 50+ years-old insurance broker.
Now, there are a lot of excellent insurance brokers in NY. But Rampart stands out for a few reasons:
Middle-Aged But Local
Not too young, not too old, Rampart has enough industry experience to stand out without being the longest-running agent in the city. It’s a decent number, but it can mean two things: Rampart is less experienced than older competitors and less flexible than young ones.
But Rampart is also a local agency. As NY has some of the most extensive building laws in the country, many local businesses may prefer one of their own to a national brand.
Business Casual
Not too stuffy, not too careless, Rampart hits the nail on the head with its business casual voice. And it’s headline is so simple, I keep asking myself, “Why didn’t I think of that?”
What is that headline?
“We’ve got you covered…and then some.”
It works because they’ve coupled everyday speech with relevance. After all, insurance is all about being covered.
Room for Improvement
That said, the copy could still be tweaked. For example, the Commercial Insurance page is almost threadbare. I would have created separate additional landing pages for their primary client types- like real estate or healthcare and fleshed out their general services and programs. Perhaps they specialize in a particular insurance product type, or there are general trends they’ve noticed.
While they have supplemental content in the form of resources and articles, I’d love to test if longer copy would boost their conversion rate.
Sunny California and Fuller Insurance Agency
Based in Southern California, Fuller Insurance also offers an array of financial products – from personal life insurance to commercial variations.
And we’ll see they have a dramatically different style than Rampart. And it’s not just because they have a dog with boxing mitts on their front page.
Divide and Conquer
Almost twenty years younger than Rampart, Fuller Insurance doesn’t emphasis its age. Instead, it subdivides its commercial insurance types and highlights its specialties.
Each of the divisions has a landing page dedicated to the topic. While the copy is still a bit short, Fuller does something you don’t see often:
- They don’t list specific products (liability, workers comp, etc.)
- Instead of immediately describing their services, they suggest questions their clients should ask when picking an insurance plan.
- Nearly all of their descriptions are in bullets.
Education to Conversion
While their Commercial Property section doesn’t list products, you will find landing pages for products under the Business section.
Here is where you will find in-depth explanations about specific policies and relevant industries. This is an excellent example of using education to push users through the funnel. Instead of immediately saying, “Get a Quote,” Fuller uses its space to prep the prospect for the call.
Could It Get Any Better?
While I’m a fan of the copy, some design elements could be optimized. For example, they could put a CTA at the end of the product landing pages, so users don’t have to scroll up to get a quote. It might also be helpful to remove the slider on the front page. Sliders rarely lead to conversions, especially in the header.
Insurance Down South – Collier Insurance
If you permit, I’m returning to my hometown of Memphis to look at Collier Insurance.
The oldest of them all, Collier opened its doors in 1911, but it doesn’t highlight that fact on its front page, strangely enough. Like Fuller, Collier Insurance focuses on its niches and partnerships to immediately suggest reliability.
More Landing Pages, More Copy
Out of the three agencies listed here, Collier has the most extensive list of landing pages per industry. These landing pages run several paragraphs, usually explaining what each policy in everyday speech, with an excellent CTA at the end of each page.
Some pages are shorter than others. For example, their Surety Bond page is just a paragraph and a list. So there’s a good amount of customization on each page.
A Bit Dry
What Collier has in straightforward design and includes more long-form, it loses in voice. Unlike Rampart and Fuller, Collier insurance maintains a more formal and dry tone throughout its copy. While the words are simple, there’s not enough personality to carry me through.
The voice is a bit on the safe side and doesn’t do enough to separate Collier from the crowd.
Summarizing These Commercial Insurance Copywriting Examples
All three of these local agencies showcase some excellent copy – with some room for tweaking. From what we’ve learned today, here’s what you can use when drafting your commercial insurance copy:
- Use educational content to highlight your expertise.
- How many years you’ve been in business may not matter. If you’re a newer agency, focus on projects, partners, and your niche.
- Insert some personality to make the copy more enjoyable to read. Insurance is already complicated for the layperson, it shouldn’t be boring!
What would you add to this list? Let me know in the comments!

