Research in the Age of Misinformation

Featured image for research workflow for writers blog post

Writing is research, and quality research be the difference between trust and suspicion for brands. Yes, your storytelling and narrative model matters. But what bolsters your emotional triggers and market positioning can’t be hype, it must be factual.

The internet made research both easier and harder. Today, we have access to millions of sources, many of them quality books, interviews, and studies. We’re also flooded with a lot of other stuff—non-expert opinions, conflict of interests paid studies, poorly performed studies, propaganda, hype, scams, and a number of other poor-quality content.

Artificial intelligence, no matter how you feel about it, accelerated propagation of misinformation. I’m not talking about intentional developments (although Grok, in particular, is known for information manipulation). I’m talking about individuals creating believable but incorrect studies, articles, emails, videos, and other materials at scale.

At the same time, you’re vying for trust over your competitors.

If writing is research, it helps to develop a strong research process on the content writing and copy-side.

There are three components to this: Identifying misinformation, sourcing legitimate information, and fact-checking prior to submission.

Let’s get into it.

It’s rarely intentional: Source of misinformation

There’s a multitude of ways to determine if information is correct or not right off the bat. I have a list, and you’ll notice that some are researcher-error as well:

  • Outdated studies*
  • Not reading a study correctly (sometimes stems from not knowing the material)
  • Actively misleading studies are the bulk
  • Poor access to source material —everything is 2nd or 3rd hand
  • Misleading surveys or results (for example, people tend to write reviews to complain more often than to advocate for a product or business.)
  • Messy or over-mapped docs (not enough information, can create confusion if not filtered)
  • Over reliance in technology (AI hallucinations, Google AI answers that pool from incorrect sources)

These are the most common problems I see, but I should also note that there are always exceptions. For example, the ACTIVE study was from published in 2019 and lasted 20 years, giving it substantial research data to study dementia. Even at seven years after its release, the quality of the data is high and still may offer findings for a medical aid product.

Most of the ways misinformation seeps into writing can corrected either by fine-tuning your research process or in the fact-checking summary.

The ideal research workflow for writers

Time-limit: 1-2 hours

Ideally, research for an blog article up to 1,500 words should take up to two hours, max. You can streamline the process by prioritizing the following types of information:

  • Scholarly materials and 1st person perspectives
  • Primary sources
  • Independent studies, ideally not sponsored by competitors but this not always possible
  • Internal materials with a filter — focus only one what’s necessary for this article
  • Internal questions and answers with company experts

I used to use Scite to identify potentially scholarly papers on the topic, but I find it just as fast to use Google Scholar or simply a search engine to identify useful articles and books. I prioritize studies, but it’s important to look at the publisher and sampling size.

If I’m writing about investors in the US stock market, I may be more wary of an article based on another locale—simply because of differences in compliance laws, financial markets, and investing expectations. But if I’m writing about emerging markets and geopolitics, I may find a useful line or two in the same study.

Independent studies are also fantastic, because they often contain industry-specific and timely information. But there are some caveats:

  • Polls are popular but the relevancy depends entirely on sampling size. A study on payments that only focuses on AP won’t necessarily give you data you can use for content on AR or CFOs. This information should be included in the methodology, either located at the beginning or end of the poll.
  • Sponsors matter. Even if an article isn’t sponsored by a direct competitor, it can affect the findings. Be critical of the questions asked and how numbers are framed. “Almost half of respondents love chocolate” may sound convincing until you see the number is only 23%, and it includes 24% of people who are indifferent. If it’s sponsored by a chocolate-favoring company, that framing matters.
  • Leverage first-person experiences with caution. Primary sources, witnesses, and so on are vital. But they may not tell the whole story. They are a human touch point, a flash of authenticity.

The process you use also matters. One problem that can emerge when quoting sources, especially in marketing when citing is lackadaisical in comparison to other disciplines, it helps to have a system to avoid accidentally plagiarism or misquoting.

I recommend:

  • Create a list of potential sources
  • Weed out the interesting bits
  • Write them in our own words in the research document
  • Integrate them into your article
  • Cite the source

This practice of writing and rewriting can ensure you comprehend the data you’re skimming and add it with brand flair and style—not almost copying from the original document.

Fact-checking in 45 minutes or less

Time-limit: 30-45 minutes

At the end of your article, you’ll want to review your facts, not just the grammar. For broad topics, website like FactCheck are obviously useful. But that might not be helpful for the nitty gritty in niche industries such as health, finance, and law.

I recommend having a checklist, and highlighting your research in the article to speed up the process. The following order has worked well for me, but it isn’t set in stone:

  1. Double check math equations
  2. Look up the source—is it a real person, a competitor, an independent party? Is there a face to the source?
  3. Reread source material — does the statistics mean what you think they mean
    1. If in doubt, email an expert
    2. Do you have an internal stakeholder who can provide insight?
  4. Try to confirm results with a secondary study, if possible
  5. Look for counter-arguments that can either be answered or should be included to provide balance

I’ve developed a sample checklist below, feel free to print or capture the questions for your own editing brief:

The end-goal is trust

At the end of the day, we aren’t researching and fact-checking to simply limit exposure for compliance or misleading business practices (although those are legit). It’s about building trust.

Most prospects aren’t going to fact-check every single piece of information. But using solid, trustworthy sources, citing them, and using data correctly elicits trust for those who do take it a step further. Balanced approaches for misconception articles are particularly useful, as prospects tend not to give up on ingrained beliefs easily. Answering objections allow these individuals to feel heard and be open to your perspective.

It’s hard to slow down when marketing is fast-paced and you have 100+ assignments in your backlog. Yet, it’s in taking that extra time that we transition from hype to authenticity.

And if you need a writer with a passion for deep research—I’m always available for a brief discovery call.